Bikes vs cars: taxes, traffic jams and sharing the road at the MotoGP

Posted: Thursday 08 July 2010 by Alison

Readers' comments

I was witness to an unpleasant motorcycle accident on the weekend when a motorist pulling onto the provincial highway near where I live, ran into a motorcyclist who finished against the guardrail (which frighteningly runs alongside a railway line but this doesn’t have to be any more dramatic than it already is). I was shopping with a friend at the time and there was a sickening feeling that while we were out buying shoes, someone could be dying just 50 metres from us.

My friend is totally against motorcycles as forms of transport. He reckons they are extremely dangerous, cars are much safer and motorcyclists always do silly things. Our opinions differ, although on the last point I’ll say that motorcyclists often do silly things and take risks that they probably shouldn’t, just because a bike is nimbler than a car. But not always.

My philosophy is often to take the reverse approach to solving a problem. I believe that as humans, we are very set in our ways and like to move with trends, and this is a mentality that holds us back. In the case of the bikes vs cars debate, my friend would argue that bikes need more limitations and that it would be better for everyone if there were less on the road. I go with exactly the opposite argument, saying that we actually need more riders on the road and drivers should be much more aware of interacting with other people - be they bikers, cyclists or pedestrians - while driving.

I noticed this in our recent behind the scenes experience at the MotoGP. Being the event that it is, thousands of motorcyclists turn up and it’s one of the few times in my life, where driving a big hire car sedan, cars have been in the minority on the roads. It is quite striking to know that you can’t occupy the entire lane and must accept that, even just for sheer numbers, the bikes have right of way. You can also fit a lot more people on the road and get there quicker - the benefits are obvious.

When you’re in the majority it’s always the safe and easy option to run with your majority and stick to what you know. You’re never the one that has to compromise. Mike Werner makes a similar point on his “In the Fast Lane” blog when he mentions that Dutch drivers would prefer to pay more tax than sit in traffic jams.

Apart from the fact that taxing people never really seems to work to solve problems (as most of us can afford a little extra for what we consider necessary, we generally pay and put up with the problem), there is a clear shortsightedness in the idea to pay more to resolve traffic problems rather than look at a solution that would actually directly deal with the problem.

As Werner says: “Of course, people could avoid traffic jams altogether by using motorcycles. Lane splitting is legal in The Netherlands, so you’d have little problems with traffic jams, and it’s more fun.” Video originally posted on TwoWheels here: “Give motorcyclists a second thought.”

1 stelle2 stelle3 stelle4 stelle5 stelle (no votes)
share this share
3 comments

Readers' comments

hide anonymous comments
  • Mike Werner

    08 Jul 2010 - 09:32 - #1
    0 punti
    Up Down

    Actually, your friend is wrong. According to the MAIDS study done for ACEM, the majority of accidents between a car and a motorcycle are caused by the car (if I remember correctly, it’s something like 70%).

    So if we take out the car equation, motorcycles are safer. If car drivers would pay more attention to bikes and the rules of the road, motorcycle accidents would be on average, not above as is now the case.

  • Profile of alisonblog

    alisonblog

    08 Jul 2010 - 10:49 - #2
    0 punti
    Up Down

    I agree. My friend thinks that because there’s nothing between you and the road on a motorcycle they are therefore more dangerous. If that were the case, we’d all be driving bubble-wrapped armoured vehicles!

  • Profile of reaktor_2004

    reaktor_2004

    14 Jul 2010 - 17:57 - #3
    0 punti
    Up Down

    But, there is just one fact about the motorcycles that could bite all of your friend’s - motorcycles don’t kill pedestrians!

Network Blogo